Page 2 of 2

Posted: 22 Feb 2007 20:37
by S-Dir
Lennon song give a pejorative view of irish history because his verses are hard. ireland is plunged in a total despair. but the singer can denounces society of ireland througout this song.

"Well it was Sunday Bloody Sunday
When they shot the people down
The cries of 13 martyrs "

derniere question (enfin)

Write a paragraph comparing the two songs, giving your opinion on them and saying which one you prefer

Posted: 22 Feb 2007 21:53
by S-Dir
vous pouvez répondre cette nuit...

réponse dernierre kestion :

songs talk about same event, "sunday bloody sunday" (in 1972, inLondonderry). These song denounce the vision of horor and sigerswant english leave Ireland for the Irish.

john lennon song's:
- He's angry with english. for him, ireland must belong irish
U2 song's:
-He denounces most clearly the society in ireland. he's fed up with viokence and he seaks a reconciliation of two sides.

I think U2 song's it's better adapted to trnsmit a message to people and I prefer this song.

Posted: 23 Feb 2007 18:25
by ANTHOS
Salut S-Dir

Je veux bien t'aider mais ce fil me semble partir dans tous les sens. Perso, je n'ai pas le temps de lire tout pour comprendre.

(A forte risque de t'agacer) Si tu presentes des questions de manière plus claire et concise, on a moins envie de zapper.

Cordialement

Andréas

Posted: 23 Feb 2007 21:24
by S-Dir
nan nan mais tu a totalement raison, j'ai fais comme ca puisque ca commencai a pressé, vu que c'était pour de matin donc j'ai tout mis en vrac...

ce n'est pas grave, la prochaine fois je m'y prendrai plus tot